I've always wondered what happened to this fine building. It seemed so odd for it to "disappear" when so many other buildings in Caddo remained standing. Now I know that it was purposely torn down (still don't know why) and the brick was recycled. Once I found this news item and knew the correct year, I found two other similar reports.
Durant Weekly News
October 18, 1946
The old landmark at Caddo, the two-story building on the north side as you enter town, is no more. Known as The McCoy building, it was at one time, when Caddo was having the Corn Carnivals, the pride of the town. Lots of good brick in the building are now being used for more modern structures.